The question of whether cedar is a hardwood is a common one, and the answer isn't a simple yes or no. It depends on how you define "hardwood." While botanically, cedar is a softwood, its properties and uses sometimes blur the lines. Let's delve deeper into the complexities of wood classifications to understand why.
What Defines a Hardwood vs. Softwood?
The terms "hardwood" and "softwood" are not solely about the wood's actual hardness. Instead, they primarily refer to the tree's reproductive structure:
-
Hardwoods: Come from deciduous (broadleaf) trees. These trees lose their leaves annually and typically have broad, flat leaves. Examples include oak, maple, cherry, and walnut. Hardwoods generally have a more complex cellular structure, making them denser and often harder.
-
Softwoods: Come from coniferous (needle-leaf) trees. These trees retain their needles year-round and typically have cones. Examples include pine, fir, spruce, and – you guessed it – cedar. Softwoods generally have a simpler cellular structure, making them less dense and often softer.
Therefore, cedar, being from a coniferous tree, is botanically classified as a softwood.
Why the Confusion? Cedar's Unique Properties
Despite its softwood classification, cedar possesses some properties that might lead to confusion. For example:
-
Durability: Certain cedar species are surprisingly durable and resistant to decay and insect damage, characteristics often associated with hardwoods. This makes it a popular choice for outdoor applications like siding and fencing.
-
Aromatic Scent: Cedar is known for its distinct and pleasant aroma, a feature that adds to its desirability for furniture, chests, and other applications.
-
Workability: Cedar is relatively easy to work with, which makes it a popular choice for woodworking projects.
What are the different types of cedar?
There are several types of cedar, each with slightly different properties. These include:
-
Western Red Cedar: Known for its exceptional rot resistance and beautiful reddish hue. It is a very popular choice for outdoor construction and interior finishes.
-
Incense Cedar: Highly aromatic, it’s prized for its scent and used often in chests and closets. Its color tends to be a lighter tan or golden brown.
-
Eastern Red Cedar: A smaller, more compact tree compared to Western Red Cedar. It offers good resistance to rot and is occasionally used for similar applications.
-
Atlantic White Cedar: Very resistant to rot and often used for exterior applications. It is known for its lighter color and fine grain.
Is cedar harder than some hardwoods?
While generally softer than most hardwoods, certain cedar species can be harder than some softer hardwoods. The Janka hardness scale (measuring resistance to denting) provides a numerical comparison, but even then, variations within cedar species exist. It's not a simple comparison to say definitively whether a particular cedar is harder than a specific hardwood.
What are the best uses for cedar wood?
Cedar's properties make it ideal for a wide array of uses, including:
- Outdoor Construction: Siding, fencing, decking (though requires proper treatment in some climates).
- Interior Finishes: Paneling, cabinetry, furniture.
- Craftwork: Carvings, boxes, chests.
- Essential Oils: The aromatic oils are used in aromatherapy and perfumery.
In conclusion, while cedar is botanically a softwood, its remarkable properties, such as durability and aroma, often lead people to misunderstand its classification. Understanding the difference between botanical classification and practical properties is key to selecting the right wood for your projects.
