Choosing the right asphalt shingles for your home is a crucial decision impacting both aesthetics and longevity. Two popular choices from CertainTeed are the Camelot and Camelot II lines. While both offer reliable protection, key differences exist regarding their features, durability, and overall value. This comprehensive guide will dissect the similarities and disparities between Camelot and Camelot II shingles, helping you make an informed choice for your roofing project.
What are the Key Differences Between Camelot and Camelot II Shingles?
The primary distinction lies in their construction and warranty. Camelot, an older model, generally offers a shorter warranty period and a slightly less sophisticated design compared to its successor, Camelot II. Camelot II boasts enhanced durability features, resulting in a longer lifespan and a more robust warranty. Let's delve into the specifics:
Warranty:
This is a major differentiating factor. Camelot II typically comes with a significantly longer warranty than Camelot, reflecting its improved construction and enhanced resistance to weathering and damage. Check the specific warranty details offered by your supplier as these can vary based on location and specific product specifications.
Construction & Durability:
While both use asphalt as a base material, the composition and layering differ, impacting their longevity. Camelot II generally incorporates superior materials and a more refined construction process, leading to better resistance against impact, wind damage, and algae growth. The enhanced durability translates to a lower risk of premature shingle failure and reduced maintenance costs over the long term.
Appearance and Style:
Although both offer a range of colors, there might be slight differences in the overall aesthetic appeal. Camelot II might offer a more refined, dimensional appearance due to advancements in manufacturing techniques and potentially a wider range of color options.
Cost:
Generally, Camelot II tends to be more expensive than Camelot due to its superior features, longer warranty, and enhanced durability. However, the increased initial cost is often offset by the longer lifespan and reduced long-term maintenance costs.
What are the pros and cons of each shingle?
Camelot Shingles:
Pros:
- Generally more affordable upfront.
- Still offers decent protection and durability.
- Available in a range of colors to suit different styles.
Cons:
- Shorter warranty compared to Camelot II.
- May be less resistant to extreme weather conditions.
- Potentially higher long-term maintenance costs.
Camelot II Shingles:
Pros:
- Longer warranty reflecting enhanced durability.
- Superior resistance to wind damage, impact, and algae.
- Improved aesthetic appeal with a more dimensional look.
- Lower long-term maintenance costs.
Cons:
- Higher initial cost compared to Camelot.
How long do Camelot and Camelot II shingles last?
The lifespan of both shingle types depends on several factors including climate, installation quality, and maintenance. However, Camelot II generally boasts a longer expected lifespan due to its superior construction. While specific numbers vary depending on the warranty and local conditions, you can expect Camelot II to potentially outlast Camelot.
Which shingle is better for my home?
The "better" shingle depends entirely on your priorities and budget. If you prioritize affordability and are comfortable with a potentially shorter lifespan and less comprehensive warranty, Camelot might suffice. However, if you value longevity, enhanced durability, and peace of mind, the added cost of Camelot II is likely justified by its superior performance and longer-term value. Carefully weigh the pros and cons based on your individual needs and circumstances before making a decision. Consult with a reputable roofing contractor for personalized advice tailored to your specific roofing requirements and local climate.
Are Camelot shingles still made?
While CertainTeed no longer actively promotes Camelot, some distributors may still have remaining stock. However, the company strongly advocates for its newer models, such as Camelot II, which represent significant advancements in technology and performance.
What is the best shingle to buy?
There isn't a single "best" shingle. The optimal choice depends on your budget, desired lifespan, aesthetic preferences, and climate conditions. Consider factors like warranty, durability, and cost-effectiveness when making your decision. Consulting a roofing professional is always recommended.
